If this were a discussion of function, I might say something. Since it isn't, the OP can put ugly fenders on his Jeep if he wants to.This thread the OP doesn't have a 4" lift but he does have the MC fenders and 33" tires.
https://wranglertjforum.com/threads/metalcloak-fender-test-on-stock-suspension-with-33s.56875/
Unfortunately many can't see past the ends of their noses and the dislike for ANYTHING MC is strong among the more vocal members but if you look around and do a search you'll find some Jeeps here are running the MC fenders.