Best Out of the Box Shocks for 4" lift, 1.25" body lift, and 35's

“Might” is the key word. 🤣 He already gambled on the 3” Rancho springs from Summitt for $110 and crapped out.
wait, the cheap 3" rancho springs were a wash? I must've missed that one.

p.s. I'm convinced their employees are all washed up used car salesmen.
shhhh one of them is very active on here, but he's still in denial.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMT
I'm getting a little worn out on my 5100's so this caught my attention.

Is the valving the same in all these shocks in the case of the KYB Monomax, 5100, 5000x, ect.? So even if it's meant for a 1500 pickup as long as the lengths match what you need you're good to go? Or am I looking for flexibility where there is none? I've got the Nth Degree shock shifter kit on and am finding that most of the shocks listed for my lift application are too long on the compression side.
 
  • Like
Reactions: R1PPLE41
So, got the KYB's earlier today and just got back from a quick test drive. Can say without a doubt there was a noticeable difference/improvement. It felt like a slightly firmer ride, but it also felt like the shocks were absorbing the punishment. With the Rancho's, it felt like the whole Jeep was taking the punishment and not the shocks. Not sure if that makes sense or not. I only ordered the front's just to see if there was a difference, but I'll be ordering a pair for the rear today. May even order a set for the JK as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jjvw and Apparition
Here's a pic with it next to the Rancho Shock. The Rancho's have less than 1,000 miles on them, so not comparing the new KYB's to worn out Rancho's.

IMG_2784.JPG
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMT and PirataCoqui
So, got the KYB's earlier today and just got back from a quick test drive. Can say without a doubt there was a noticeable difference/improvement. It felt like a slightly firmer ride, but it also felt like the shocks were absorbing the punishment. With the Rancho's, it felt like the whole Jeep was taking the punishment and not the shocks. Not sure if that makes sense or not. I only ordered the front's just to see if there was a difference, but I'll be ordering a pair for the rear today. May even order a set for the JK as well.
Nice! You are describing something similiar to what a good Fox tune will do.
 
Nice! You are describing something similiar to what a good Fox tune will do.
That's good to hear, as the tuned Fox's are what I was eventually planning on putting on here. Too many other things in life going on at the moment to spend the money on them, but seems like these KYB's will serve me well until then. I cut the ribbon off the one to get the pic next to the Rancho, and the KYB was not easy to compress...and I'm a relatively strong person, or so I thought!
 
  • Like
Reactions: jjvw
So, ordered a pair of the KYB's for the rear and have to say, I don't care for them. Up front, they were a noticeable improvement over the Rancho's. The rear KYB's just seem too firm for my Jeep, which is probably due to my rig being fairly light at the moment. Thinking I'm going to put the Rancho's back on the rear for now and put the KYB's on the shelf. I'll give them another try down the road when the Jeep has a little more aftermarket weight on it.
 
Why is it that these Jeeps seem so sensitive to shock changes?
I'm the furthest from an expert, but I would guess the short wheelbase and overall lack of weight. I've had Pro Comp, Rancho, and KYB on mine within the past 6 months and each one was a very different feel. Right now, the KYB in the front and Rancho in the rear is the best I've found for my preference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMT and RMETeeJay
So, over the weekend I finished up some projects on the fiancés JK. While I was working on it, decided to throw the KYB's on the rear. These were way too firm for me on the TJ and knowing that the JK is a little heavier, thought it would be interesting to see how they performed on the JK compared to the TJ. As I was expecting, they felt way better on the JK. Still a tad too firm for my liking, but definitely tolerable. I know this isn't a JK forum, but thought it was worth sharing. I've been through a few different sets of "budget shocks" the last few months and its been really interesting to see how each one give such a different feel. Also goes to show how delicate the shocks choices are according to each rig and it's weight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMT and Apparition
On a side note, I hadn't driven the JK in some time. While this was my first Jeep and holds a special place in my heart, I couldn't wait to get back in my TJ.
 
I wouldnt mind trying a new pair of front shocks. Seems foxes and a few of the remote reservoirs have been on marketplace recently...
 
  • Like
Reactions: rasband
Reviving an old thread to add my thoughts. I recently installed four Rancho RS5000X shocks, and I can't rave enough. Here's why. For eleven years I've owned my TJ and I've had unknown shocks, Pro Comp, Rubicon Express, and Fox 2.0 reservoir shocks. The Ranchos are the best so far for on-road handling. For eleven years I thought it was normal for a TJ to knock your kidneys through your B-hole. Ranchos have proven otherwise. Now for context. My Jeep has a 4.0L manual trans, slip yoke eliminator, fully stock axles with 3:73 gears, 33" tires, 4.5" Rubicon Express spring lift, Rubicon Express RE3720 lower adjustable super-ride control arms up front (the rest are stock). I don't have any other add-ons to add or reduce weight. Almost all of my driving is on pavement, though my Fox shocks were not very good off road either. I paid $218 for the set of 4 Rancho shocks and it might be the best money I've spent thus far.

interesting that you like the Rancho more than the Fox. You think it's because of more street driving?