I'd say it depends on what you do with it? Tons of rock crawling and limited trail riding distance, deeper ratio would be fine. I have basically same setup, 4.56 gears, 32rh, 35s. I went with 3.8 ratio on atlas. I've never felt like I've needed a deeper ratio, but where I ride, I do get annoyed having to leave low range to be able to travel faster between obstacles. In 3rd gear low range, I am cruising at 3k rpms around 10mph. For any distance, that gets annoying real quick. I don't regret my choice, and am glad its not any deeper. Again, I feel like how you intend to use it should dictate your ratio choice, not "just because they offer it"