I originally had a set of Husky's that came with the TJ. My girlfriend got me a set of Weathertech matts and I really like them. They are thicker matts and the fit is perfect.
Don't run floor mats in the jeep anymore but I just got weathertech mats for my truck, the fit is awesome and quality is great. I may consider getting a set for the jeep
I have a set of quadratecs heavy mats in my 03 and they are ok fit well but I have a set of weathertec"s in my 01 and really like them, fit like a glove and are easy to remove and replace to clean out.
Another for WeatherTec. Mine came with Quadratec mats which I thought were quite good. Much better than really needed, but got the WeatherTec for a birthday.
Don't know how much either cost, but both sets are more than good enough. Both can hold a huge amount of slush or water. I can recommend both.
I just installed the quadratecs , also had them in my last yj, I really have been pleased with them. I have weathertec in my suburban , I had to put a screw into the kick panel because the edge had curled inward .
My Bestops are hard, I think I read before that the Qtech/Bestop and at least one more were all made the same with different private labels. But I can't confirm that.
I have the Quadratec mats and they fit well. My only complaint is the pattern is quite deep and can catch the back of my footwear occasionally. They are a stiffer material, more plastic like than rubber like.
They look identical to both the Bestop and Rugged Ridge so I suspect they're all identical and just rebranded.
In my opinion the Qt's are hard to beat for the price, the Wtecs were in my suburban when I bought it , I would never pay that much for them. I may even swap them out and put them on CL. They do what they were intended but don't stay in place very well.