2004 should be an auto. I don't think stick was available in the unlimiteds until 2005.
Might as well grab this while you're down here:
https://sanantonio.craigslist.org/pts/d/san-antonio-2004-jeep-4x4-auto/7018530598.html
Still trying to figure out from the seller if it's a 42RE or a 42RLE, if it came from a Jeep Grand Cherokee or a Jeep Cherokee (aka Liberty).
Unfortunately this seller has been a little difficult to communicate with. He may prefer phone calls to texts but I prefer texting for precision, and it's been hard to get the answer in writing.
He said on the phone it came out of a 2004 Jeep Cherokee with a v6. That sounds like the Jeep Liberty which I think (I'm still learning!) would make it the 42RLE. But most people call that a Liberty, not a Cherokee. So when I showed him pictures of the Liberty vs Grand Cherokee he indicated the picture of the Grand Cherokee and said the transmission in the Wrangler and Cherokee are the same. But he pointed to the one with the 42RE. When I explained that and said I didn't think the 42RE would go in a Wrangler, he said he would install it for me if I wanted. When I said I appreciated the offer but I just needed to be 100% sure and asked again if it's a 42RE from a Grand Cherokee or a 42RLE from a Liberty, he went silent.
Is the 42RE even a bolt-in swap? And I'm not sure I'd want to swap in a transmission that's already got 85k miles.
So I see the other side as well.
I'm a programmer, so I'm probably on the extreme opposite side of where your dad was. My grandma sounds like your dad. She always says she has done fine without it so far, and she's right! Thanks for the perspective. I'll give this guy the benefit of the doubt and give him a phone call in a little bit.
Thanks for the lead! I contacted the seller and he is going to hold onto it until I get a chance to check it out this weekend.
It's an auto. The frame looks awesome according to pictures he sent me. Single owner with all the miles in San Antonio area.
Kind of a long distance for me but I think it'll be worth it, even after flying, shipping, a new tranny, and some TLC.
We'll see! Currently waiting for him to put in writing that he'll hold onto it for me, but I'm excited!