Before I applied the butyl, I made some floor repairs (typical YJ cracks), sanded areas that had rust, and then applied POR-15. On the butyl itself, I applied as typical (with roller) and secured the seams with 2" wide HVAC duct tape. In the ~2 years of use, I never had an issue with the butly coming off or loose, including getting it wet a handful of times (my windshield channel leaked at first and I had some holes in the side of the tub that let in a lot more water than I expected). I eventually made those repairs and the butyl looked just like it did when I applied it. When I first started using butyl mat (Dynamat), I never had any issues with water either. The bond, if prepared properly, is quite strong and secure.