I’ve sold wheels and tires on Craigslist before and I also check everyday FB marketplace and Craigslist for wheel
and tires. People usually ask $100 per wheel and tire. So a set of five is like $500. Newer JK/JL rubicon takeoffs with low miles pretty brand new tires go for like $1000-1300 for a set of 5. But honestly it will sit for awhile if you ask too much. Your set looks nice and only 3k miles on the tires. I actually have the same set in 31s with same wheels that I’m looking to unload so I can go to 33s. Only 4K miles on my tires. I just don’t think I’ll get anything near the $1250 I paid for it all new. I don’t think I would fetch more than $500. So I’m looking to sell maybe just the tires and keep my wheels.
But to answer your question for your set I would start at $900-1000 asking.