As a follow up, I got new BFG KO2's put on yesterday. Not a ton of difference from the mud-terrains, but definitely quieter. But this morning I put 2 new Rancho 5000X shocks on the fronts (I'm still waiting for the rears to be delivered), and wow what a difference in ride quality. I hate to use a cliché, but it really is almost night and day difference. And when I compressed my old shocks to take them off, they didn't expand. They stayed compressed. So obviously, they were beyond bad. So if anyone is looking to replace some old shocks and concerned about ride quality difference, I would recommend the 5000x's, as many members already have.
Glad to hear it worked out for you!