Either top would be great. Pop out windows vs. two piece top...although I have to say that in the 7 years I had a JK with the freedom top with the removable front panels, I only had them off 4 or 5 times in all those years. It seemed I either had the hard top on or off, nothing in between.you are right the rally top is local but the pop out windows are cool, i guess not a bad problem to have either way it will be cool. I was thinking with the two piece I could always take off the back piece and put some mesh netting in when we go to the beach and then put the back piece back on when we go to the mountains.