*UPDATE*
After sending all the reciepts and parts list, they re-evalutated the Jeep through their third party and it didnt add a cent…somewhat understandably.
After pressing them and pushing back, Progressive worked on options, and offered me a check for their full valuation number and to keep the Jeep no questions asked, no title work, and I get it fixed where I want. (progressive’s value was $8,400/totaled)
I do have to sign a liablity release form stating I’m taking the check and wont hold Progressive or their driver liable for anything further.
Happy, they originally said it was worth $8,400, wanted to total it, and buy it from me. I got them to agree to pay me the $8,400 and I’m keeping the Jeep.