Rear Main Seal Still Leaking

I am also trying to tackle the RMS, I have an 05 LJ and it never leaked until I started running Amsoil. Has been leaking for a while and I have been putting it off until I had to replace the harmonic balancer and ended up replacing timing chain and seal and valve cover seal and things have snowballed from there! My question is I have noticed a little defect on the housing where the upper seal goes on the rear main. Am I just doomed for oil leaks with the damage here or is it possible to successfully stop this leak? It hasn’t been a drip or two either i have to park above an oil pan in my garage to avoid a mess. Not bad enough I have to constantly add oil but enough to make a mess. I attached a picture showing how much it leaks, granted that is over some time and the other shows the damage. Thanks in advance for any advice

A2AA065A-6803-4386-AB2B-F7ADB18DA74B.jpeg


E3026520-D90C-4C10-A84A-A0E95E8C42B4.jpeg
 
Shouldn't be much of an issue. The seal is pressed between the crankshaft and the surface where your pick tool is resting. A small amount of quality sealant applied sparingly in that area would not be a bad idea either.
 
Changed mine 3 times in a span of 3 days, could not stop the leak. Kind or type of oil has no effect on it.
You expected a miracle within 3 days, that doesn't happen when using a high mileage conventional oil to restore the seals. Mine took a few more days than that but it did completely cure my bad RMS leak. The type of oil DOES have an effect on this, it's well known and is why they make High Mileage versions of engine oils.
 
I am also trying to tackle the RMS, I have an 05 LJ and it never leaked until I started running Amsoil. Has been leaking for a while and I have been putting it off until I had to replace the harmonic balancer and ended up replacing timing chain and seal and valve cover seal and things have snowballed from there! My question is I have noticed a little defect on the housing where the upper seal goes on the rear main. Am I just doomed for oil leaks with the damage here or is it possible to successfully stop this leak? It hasn’t been a drip or two either i have to park above an oil pan in my garage to avoid a mess. Not bad enough I have to constantly add oil but enough to make a mess. I attached a picture showing how much it leaks, granted that is over some time and the other shows the damage. Thanks in advance for any advice

View attachment 264262

View attachment 264263
I don't think your doomed. You have to use anaerobic sealer on the bearing cap anyways so I would put an extremely small amount closer to where the notch is. Looks like it would help to clean up the crank as well.
 
Ok i remember now.
When i replaced my crank i had a 1 piece seal when the kit came with to pieces i was like WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA.
 
Ok i remember now.
When i replaced my crank i had a 1 piece seal when the kit came with to pieces i was like WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA.
I was replacing a power steering pump one time and I asked the guy at the parts store if I needed DOT 3 or DOT 4 fluid.

He said, "Well I usually don't use brake fluid for a power steering pump"

My mind was in a different place at the moment
 
Shit can get real. My supra had to use *clutch fluid* from toyota was super expensive..............except that fool worked same on dot3
 
My TJ never leaked a drop of oil from any part of the engine. Last year when I was replacing my clutch & had everything apart I was looking at the RMS & thinking how this would be a great time to replace it as a preventative maintenance item, would have been really easy with the trans out. The ‘don’t fix it if it aint broke’ mentality haunted me & I passed, buttoned it all back up.

The RMS began leaking the very moment I returned from my first post-clutch install test drive and hasn’t stopped since :oops:.

Somewhere in the universe some force or being is pissing its pants laughing at me.

Oh, as far as your question, I'd say flip a coin.
Every time fate closes a door, it opens a window. Then pees out of it onto my life.
 
Let me guess you're running a synthetic engine oil. If you are, that commonly causes the RMS to start shrinking/shriveling due to a lack of seal enhancers in many of them. Try this, which normally works to restore the RMS and stop leaks. It sealed my BMW's big RMS leak within a week. Simply change the engine oil to a conventional High Mileage 10W-30, my bet is the leak will be gone within a week of driving. The High Mileage version of a conventional engine oil has additional amounts of seal restoring products that can help insure the seal does its job.
I let someone drive my 03 with 61,000 miles.

They said “your rear main leaks ! Danger Will Robinson”

I said “so”.

I’m not touching it.
 
You expected a miracle within 3 days, that doesn't happen when using a high mileage conventional oil to restore the seals. Mine took a few more days than that but it did completely cure my bad RMS leak. The type of oil DOES have an effect on this, it's well known and is why they make High Mileage versions of engine oils.
No, only thing I expect is stop of leaks after seal change, regardless of oil.

Since you always put emphasis on your high mileage oil, I did go 6000 miles on penzoil conventional high mileage that advertises expansion of seals to stop leaks. Then I switched back to amsoil, no difference what so ever.
Only difference was between bad seal and good seal.
 
No, only thing I expect is stop of leaks after seal change, regardless of oil.

Since you always put emphasis on your high mileage oil, I did go 6000 miles on penzoil conventional high mileage that advertises expansion of seals to stop leaks. Then I switched back to amsoil, no difference what so ever.
Only difference was between bad seal and good seal.
My apologies to both of us for having tried to help you. No worries, it won't happen again.