Shock Comparison: Rancho RS5000X vs Skyjacker Black Max vs KYB Monotube

Jamesval035

TJ Enthusiast
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2018
Messages
764
Location
Cameron, nc
Ya, once I get back home from work today I'll trim out the minimum to clear the shock body. Im also dealing with some steering wandering after Currectlync install and alignment. While going over the front end earlier, I found my frame side tracker bar bolt has a lot of movement. so thinking that is it. and....some more bad news, my water pump is leaking..smh again.
 

suicideking

TJ Addict
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2019
Messages
1,725
Location
Riverside, CA
Bumping this one...

Just got a stock TJ and it has the KYB Monomax. These are too bouncy for my tastes. This not going to see much (if any) off road, using it for my DD and will keep it stock height. So thinking of the options mentioned, sounds like the Skyjacker Black Max might be more what I'm looking for. Any others I should consider? Never liked Bilstein. Sounds like the Rancho aren't as nice as the Skyjacker for DD.

There's a section of the freeway on my commute that is bouncy, I call it the whoops section. I had the same problem with a stock F150. In my Expedition, LJ, and even wife's Prius, this section is not noticeable.
 

jjvw

secret beadlocks
Supporting Member
Ride of the Month Winner
Joined
Feb 17, 2018
Messages
23,648
Location
Colorado, USA
Bumping this one...

Just got a stock TJ and it has the KYB Monomax. These are too bouncy for my tastes. This not going to see much (if any) off road, using it for my DD and will keep it stock height. So thinking of the options mentioned, sounds like the Skyjacker Black Max might be more what I'm looking for. Any others I should consider? Never liked Bilstein. Sounds like the Rancho aren't as nice as the Skyjacker for DD.

There's a section of the freeway on my commute that is bouncy, I call it the whoops section. I had the same problem with a stock F150. In my Expedition, LJ, and even wife's Prius, this section is not noticeable.

Bouncy meaning they allow for a lot of uncontrolled movement?
 

Jerry Bransford

TJ Guru Moderator
Staff Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2015
Messages
27,247
Location
Fleming Island Florida
Bumping this one...

Just got a stock TJ and it has the KYB Monomax. These are too bouncy for my tastes. This not going to see much (if any) off road, using it for my DD and will keep it stock height. So thinking of the options mentioned, sounds like the Skyjacker Black Max might be more what I'm looking for. Any others I should consider? Never liked Bilstein. Sounds like the Rancho aren't as nice as the Skyjacker for DD.

There's a section of the freeway on my commute that is bouncy, I call it the whoops section. I had the same problem with a stock F150. In my Expedition, LJ, and even wife's Prius, this section is not noticeable.
What tire size are you running and exactly what air pressure is in them?
 

TeeJohn

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2019
Messages
78
Location
Kentucky
I installed Black Max on the front this summer. They are softer than the old EMU Nitro Chargers. The Jeep has softer feel on small bumps and sharp turns. I like them. I kept the OME on the rear since I have a big tire on a carrier and a bumper.
 

Mike_H

autos are better - WRWD508
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2017
Messages
10,374
Location
Grand Rapids, MI, United States
Bumping this one...

Just got a stock TJ and it has the KYB Monomax. These are too bouncy for my tastes. This not going to see much (if any) off road, using it for my DD and will keep it stock height. So thinking of the options mentioned, sounds like the Skyjacker Black Max might be more what I'm looking for. Any others I should consider? Never liked Bilstein. Sounds like the Rancho aren't as nice as the Skyjacker for DD.

There's a section of the freeway on my commute that is bouncy, I call it the whoops section. I had the same problem with a stock F150. In my Expedition, LJ, and even wife's Prius, this section is not noticeable.

Mono max are the red ones? You might try the silver KYBs. I was going to, but they only offer them for stock height rigs. IIRC, the guy you bought that Jeep from drove a rig with them and thought they were “passable.”
 

suicideking

TJ Addict
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2019
Messages
1,725
Location
Riverside, CA
Mono max are the red ones? You might try the silver KYBs. I was going to, but they only offer them for stock height rigs. IIRC, the guy you bought that Jeep from drove a rig with them and thought they were “passable.”

Yes, the red KYB Monomax. They seem a bit rough, remind me of the Bilstein 5100. Not terrible, but the Skyjacker black max aren't that expensive.
 

Mike_H

autos are better - WRWD508
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2017
Messages
10,374
Location
Grand Rapids, MI, United States
Yes, the red KYB Monomax. They seem a bit rough, remind me of the Bilstein 5100. Not terrible, but the Skyjacker black max aren't that expensive.

I thought the same. Pretty harsh in the rear. I think the silver ones are called gas-a-just or something. They are not very expensive either. I haven't run them on the TJ, but I do have them on my motorhome and they work well there. The black maxs have not shown to have good longevity on my jeep. They are not the shocks now that I installed two years ago, and I've already put a new set of rear ones on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: suicideking

TJ Jim

TJ Addict
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2021
Messages
1,190
Location
Tennessee
Just ordered a set of black max last Friday. Going from OME shocks that ride like an unloaded log truck so I’m hoping they will be better. Ordered rancho 5000 twice from Amazon and twice got the wrong/bad shocks. Gave up and ordered direct from Skyjacker. Maybe this week I’ll be riding on new shocks.