The backspacing for your wheels depends on which wheels you have, but I think most of the 15” wheels had a 5.5” backspacing. Alex01 is right, the 12.5 will likely rub a bit. The 10.5 should fit better, as well as being slightly cheaper and better on/off road. There was an excellent article written on expedition west several years ago that went through the reasons why. Very good read if you are mechanically minded and want the reasons why narrow is better.