I have two objections to automatics: 1) They're expensive and less reliable, and 2) They're BORING.
Car dealers have been apolgists for automatics for decades. I remember telling a Ford dealer, "Ok. So you want me to spend $1,000 more for the automatic, be bored out of my skull the entire time, then at trade-in time I'll get an extra $300? I call that a 'net loss'". He had been telling me how the auto would bring more money at trade-in time...
Now the price differential is about $2,500 and they are touted as "more efficient". Maybe so, but $2,500 will buy a LOT of gasoline. Spending that kind of money to gain an extra 1-2 MPG (if that) is ridiculous - unless you're a Greenie. Never mind that many of them are unreliable as Hell, and cost many thousands to repair/replace. The old GM TH-400 would go the distance, some of the new ones will too - but many won't and either way, you pay for it. Through the ass...