After reading this I was curious and went to the Qtec site, This was my favorite part of your review:3rd times a charm. Maybe.
I was bored yesterday so I installed the 3rd Mastertop I have sitting sitting in my garage.
Quadratec sent me a 3rd replacement top for the issue I've been having even though I requested a Bestop.
This top fits much better than the other two tops. The top section is much tighter, no slack. The side windows fit perfect, but the rear window was very sloppy. So I frankensteined the top by using the rear window from one of the other tops.
Everything fit nice, Road tested and much quieter than the 2 previous tops. I have yet to take it on the highway to see how it sounds at 65mph. If its all good, I'll keep it.
"This is by far the worst top I ever had on any of my jeeps. The noise that is generated by this top is so bad. The flapping starts at 30mph and becomes so bad on the highway at 60-70mph,it sounds like the top in going to tear off."