What do you guys think is the best aftermarket soft top?

Bestop is the only brand with windows that will work on factory tops. Also, not sure what year you have, but there were changes in materials and zippers. Up until 01 the factory color was Black Denim, 02 & up was Black Diamond. 2000 & 2001 had a 3 layer sailcloth, 02 & up had a 2 layer sailcloth. Zippers on windows up until 01 were opposite (1 side window had male 1/2 and the other side window had female 1/2) on 02 & up the the zippers were the same on both sides. I found all this out after TONS of research and shopping. I ended up going for the Bestop Sailcloth and I couldn't be happier ! Hope this helps.

Are you sure Black Denim wasn't the color for 2002? I was on the Bestop site and Black Diamond was not a color option for 2002 soft top. thanks
 
Are you sure Black Denim wasn't the color for 2002? I was on the Bestop site and Black Diamond was not a color option for 2002 soft top. thanks

Black denim was the color from 97-02. 03-06 they switched to the black diamond color.