Well, I was about to crash this party after my palms started itching but I see we have moved on to turning Jeeps into Priusisesis now?
Stroking a 4.0 from a strictly HP performance perspective is polishing a turd. Any HP mod to a 4.0 is really. There are too many limiting factors as mentioned above to ever make it a practical base for real performance.
That being said, the big selling point of a stroker was/kinda is the cheap cost with junkyard parts compared to a normal rebuild. Parts are becoming more scarce though, and aftermarket is expensive. You also start rapidly losing that bang for the buck when you start trying to make it actually breath with head work, a big cam, compression, fancy bolt ons, etc. Not saying it won't make more power, but your point of diminishing returns n/a starts around 300hp which isn't much.
And people bag on reliability of strokers. There is ZERO less reliable about a stroker per se. What does cause problems is higher lift cams eating lobes, high pressure oil pumps putting stress on things, and bad machining/assembly. All of these issues would be the same on a rebuilt 4.0 with the same things done. Has nothing to do with the stroke.
All that being said, what kind of crazy ass hole would dump money into one? Me
It's the motor Jeep should have installed from the factory. It's more than spunky (think Fox body Mustang fast to around 70) and will cruise up hill doing 80 on 33's with 4.10s all day long at half throttle. I love the motor. I also enjoy wrenching and have a weird obsession for more power in everything, so there it is.