Although they are clear coated and shouldn't need polishing I've abandoned the AR23's. Another member who lives in the NE and has AR23s share a few pics of the failing clear coat.
@97JadeTJ notes as well. Dealing with damaged clear coat is likely worse than having to polish the ProComps. So, to this point I have done nothing with regard to replacing what I have. Polishing them isn't horrible, only time consuming. I just did it again last week in preparation for winter since my TJ is a DD.
The upkeep is only one factor in my search for new wheels.. I have 15x10 installed by the PO and I want 15x8 or 8.5.