I did this as well. If I recall, what showed up had no branding so I can't say who made what I actually got, but I can say the seal didn't do the job. The current seal is from Fairchild Industries and it isn't any better, might actually be worse.
I haven't had an issue with fit on any of them thus far, in so far as fitting the door itself (plastic pin quantities and locations, size/length of seal). The issue I'm having is the profile and rubber types uses for specific features, and how those features seal to the door jamb in the tub and hardtop roof. The main problem areas are the top and upper forward edges. Without photos, attempting to go into any more detail at the moment would probably prove pointless, but I'm finding the whole thing a bit frustrating as the passenger footwell gets soaked every time it rains. Instead of sealing and diverting water, it would seem to be doing the exact opposite. Right now I'm in for ~$100 of seals on the passenger door alone and I'm not sure where else to look for decent parts.
Oh, and the door is very hard to close, true for both replacement seals so far. I'll see about getting some photos to better illustrate the issues.