What will look better on my TJ, a stubby bumper or a full bumper?

We cut this stock one and added the Mopar Stubby end caps.
7CA88FBC-2DD1-49E2-8D71-90B8000B186E.jpeg
BF0422B6-03A4-497A-8AF3-84BB153935D7.jpeg

On this one I went with a Warn Stubby.
89F0D553-3A19-4B44-BF0B-337633386744.jpeg
 
I ordered this 43" bumper from KD Fabworks. I liked it because it's made in USA, you can order it powdercoated, comes with a fairlead bracket, and I can mount lights on the bumper outer ends and on the trail bar.

http://www.kdfabworks.com/97-06-TJ-Front-Rock-Crawler-43-Bumper-with-Trail-Bar_p_22.html
I think I've settled on the KD Fab too, still waffling between the 43" and the 49" both are shorter than the 54" stock (no jugs) bumper
Leaning more towards the 43" but I'll probably change my mind another 27 times