I just saw a 2006 Rubicon Wrangler listed on Craigslist. It’s listed for $30K. From the pics it looks pretty clean and it’s very low miles. I went to Kelly blue book and it books a little under $20K if it’s in excellent condition. Here’s a link to it. I’m tempted to go look at it and see what it’s like. If it’s in good condition maybe offer them $20K for it and see what they say. I’m sure they only paid what it books for at the most.