Ok, what about it
@toximus? What do you think of the RubiCrawler?
Wow. Chris had to sell his (in)famous TJ...I must be living under a rock, I knew nothing of this...
Hmm... where to start...
I had been thinking about purchasing a Rubicrawler for my red LJ which has a NP231 because I just don't like the 2.71 ratio for anything. For snow wheeling it's difficult to keep the tires going a consistent speed so the solution is more torque. I hadn't had really any quantity of time with a NP241 (Rubicon transfer case) so I figured a 7.40 ratio sounded good.
I took the khaki Jeep (35s, 5.38 gears, and 42RLE) offroad on a light rock trail in Johnson Valley and I found that I was happy in 4lo (4:1 ratio). Between rock sections through the sand (15mph+) I shifted back into high (1:1 ratio). Foot off the gas in 4lo I was able to let it idle going up hill. For the rocky hill climb that I did the week earlier I just let it rip in 2hi. The one time that I used "double low" (10.88:1) was to get up on a set of car ramps front and rear that I kept messing up getting onto and they'd slide out from under — in this scenario the lower ratio smoothed out my foot a bit, we were rushing before sunset and I think it got to me, I would consider this driver error.
In these experiences I have a difficult time recommending the Rubicrawler on a properly setup Jeep and will actually be holding off on buying one for under my red LJ until I decide I actually want anything more than 4:1. I don't want the 2.71 ratio in my red LJ.
The Rubicrawler may be perfectly suited for a manual Jeep where you DO want a lower ratio (but obviously this product doesn't fit), or
MAYBE if you had a NP231 (2.71) with a Dana 30 front and could go with the shallower 5.13 gears in the diffs.
To get deeper offroad ratios into a Jeep with the 2.71 swapping in a Rubicon 241 is expensive for a chain driven design in my opinion, if you can even find one... The Rubicrawler ends up going too deep and also costs a lot. I will probably end up looking into an Atlas someday to get the gearing I want. With some dimpling an Atlas fits with a tummy tuck so there's little issue there (fits similar to a NP241J), and the outputs are short enough to allow for safe driveline angles. Right now I don't have the time to install one so I'm sticking with the NP231J.
To give a definitive answer, I need to do a lot more wheeling with it than I have in more types of terrain. The Rubicrawler does give you options and a fun extra lever to play with but if those options aren't what you want, what good is having options?