A 195 degree Stant SuperStat would be a great choice, and avoid store-brand water pumps... they're so cheaply made they're not worth installing. Don't let the "lifetime warranty" fool you into thinking it must be good quality, it's not and that is just a marketing gimmick. They'll give you a free replacement, sure, but you'd need it way sooner than if you had bought the good quality Mopar water pump in the first place. I'd take a Mopar water pump with its one year warranty any day over a store-brand water pump with a lifetime warranty.
Here's the real deal, a Mopar water pump at a great price... more than a store-brand but it's worth it. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B009DKISHK/?tag=wranglerorg-20
Last suggestion, Zerex G-05 coolant mixed 50-50 with distilled water. Avoid using tap water.
Jeez, $124.75 from amazon.com and $276.44 from amazon.ca U.S. border, here I come!
I have one of these tools from my GM days.
http://www.gearwrench.com/gearwrench-3900-universal-pulley-holder.html