I need help choosing a new soft top

Sarahanne1984

New Member
Original poster
Joined
Mar 26, 2018
Messages
13
Location
Gulfport, FL
D589D5A7-87CE-413B-8116-5C7CA21B28B9.webp
D589D5A7-87CE-413B-8116-5C7CA21B28B9.webp
C5358D27-6E38-4069-8CE3-943D5F62CE33.webp
79ACD207-9457-44CC-9640-73F0B0F8BE75.webp
I need some help choosing what brand of soft top to go with. I need a fast back bowless top- I like the ones where just the front can flip back when you want and not have to take the whole thing off every time.
I had the pavement ends sprint top in black diamond because it was the cheapest... probably the mistake I made.
A raccoon was able to rip it apart and eat a big hole in the roof over the drivers side! No joke.
I’m wondering if the other brands or more expensive ones or if I chose a different fabric would be tougher and harder for an animal to tear it up? Please help I’m dying to get this hard top off!
 
The ONLY brand I'd go with is Bestop and their Sailcloth top is the longest lasting, best quality, and produces the quietest interior. It's not cheap but it'll last many years. Quadratec sells a top they say uses Sailcloth but comments from owners of it about it say it doesn't fit nearly as well and because it fits looser, it flaps more and makes for a noisier interior than the Bestop top does.
 
I have the bestop trektop it’s starting to Rip from where you undo it from the top of the doors. It got like that from flipping the front half back and also when you flip it back the zippers from the rear windows get messed up . the zippers come undone
Now I can’t take my windows off (I also bought it for $300 about half the orginal price) I would have been upset if I bought full price and this happens.

6C2C75B8-4AF0-4F6F-B8F1-5520BF82D53B.webp


F4EDAD00-D628-4BF3-B409-176D0086F528.webp


9B09B044-3B19-4574-9323-1D291198692B.webp


84081E0F-022A-4759-9D0C-851D699335B3.webp
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Sarahanne1984
I have the bestop trektop it’s starting to Rip from where you undo it from the top of the doors. It got like that from flipping the front half back and also when you flip it back the zippers from the rear windows get messed up . the zippers come undone
Now I can’t take my windows off (I also bought it for $300 about half the orginal price) I would have been upset if I bought full price and this happens.
Good to know. I was looking into that top in the twill cloth. Really expensive but the manufacturer said that was the thicker fabric choice.. I didnt have any problems like that with my sprint top. It was great structurally for a year and a half even though it was cheap until a raccoon ate through the fabric and ate the foam out of the tailgate bar too. I’m not really worried about insulating from road or wind noise or anything like that. Just wondering if there’s a cloth choice that might be harder for an animal to tear apart. I’d hate to buy a new top and have it come right back and do it again since I can’t figure out why it did it in the first place. Came back two nights in a row. Also wondering if all the choices could be torn apart just as easily...
 
Good to know. I was looking into that top in the twill cloth. Really expensive but the manufacturer said that was the thicker fabric choice.. I didnt have any problems like that with my sprint top. It was great structurally for a year and a half even though it was cheap until a raccoon ate through the fabric and ate the foam out of the tailgate bar too. I’m not really worried about insulating from road or wind noise or anything like that. Just wondering if there’s a cloth choice that might be harder for an animal to tear apart. I’d hate to buy a new top and have it come right back and do it again since I can’t figure out why it did it in the first place. Came back two nights in a row. Also wondering if all the choices could be torn apart just as easily...
The twill fabric is considerably thicker and more durable in appearance than the sailcloth. I've always gone with the sailcloth, as Jerry said, but I have been eyeing a Twill soft top..The tops on the Jeeps I've seen with the twill look so much more substantial. Hit up @Starrs, I believe he got a twill replacement top.
 
One more note Saharanne1984, the Bestop Sailcloth top is what new Jeeps after about 2001 come with. It was the factory's OEM top. I've seen the Bestop twill top and my BMW came with a twill top too but I'd rather have Sailcloth (and do have) for my Wrangler.
 
DDF377F8-65E1-4CCD-A5E7-F128435E2ACA.webp
The twill fabric is considerably thicker and more durable in appearance than the sailcloth. I've always gone with the sailcloth, as Jerry said, but I have been eyeing a Twill soft top..The tops on the Jeeps I've seen with the twill look so much more substantial. Hit up @Starrs, I believe he got a twill replacement top.
It’s a damn nice soft top, but I will admit it’s hard to shell out a grand for a soft top. Sail cloth would be a nice option to go with also. I got mine on amazon prime for 879 I think it was so I got a little discount on mine. It’s not flap proof at 50+ mph on the interstate but it is a hell of a lot more quieter than the OEM Mopar top I had. I fully endorse it just based on aesthetics alone, but the sound barrier the thicker fabric provides is an added bonus. Just really boils down to how much are you willing to spend on a soft top. Attached is a pic of my OEM top. The color difference in the fabrics sold me also.
 
D878A309-79F6-4CD1-A911-B2482E42AE4D.webp
View attachment 36974 View attachment 36974 View attachment 36975 View attachment 36976 I need some help choosing what brand of soft top to go with. I need a fast back bowless top- I like the ones where just the front can flip back when you want and not have to take the whole thing off every time.
I had the pavement ends sprint top in black diamond because it was the cheapest... probably the mistake I made.
A raccoon was able to rip it apart and eat a big hole in the roof over the drivers side! No joke.
I’m wondering if the other brands or more expensive ones or if I chose a different fabric would be tougher and harder for an animal to tear it up? Please help I’m dying to get this hard top off!
Black twill in this pic.
 
I've had the Bestop Trek Twill on my 06 TJ X for a few years now, and have not had any of the issues described in one of the above posts. I've made numerous cross states trips in severe snow and ice storms, and severe heat, top still looks new and works great. A lot less cabin noise compared to lighter material soft tops. I do garage my jeep when not in use, so it isn't exposed 24/7 like some. I do use it as a daily driver though. No leaks either.....
Ray
 
Geez lol have they showed you how you can stretch the pic to enlarge it? I can walk you through it if you need any help.
No, I know how to do that including using Photoshop on a regular basis. Not to mention you lose detail and resolution when you stretch a photo to enlarge and crop it. But more importantly, it's just better to position the camera close enough to the subject so it is properly exposed so you can see detail and texture instead of just a black outline. Non-photographers invariably stand too far back from what they're photographing. There's nothing wrong with asking someone to stand closer or even use a flash when taking photos for use in figuring out a question or issue.
 
Last edited:
OK, I'm going to jump in here with a specific question about Bestop sailcloth vs. Bestop twill. This would be a replacement top on my '99 SE and also for a '12 JKU.

The SE spends significant time on tight trails. The top gets rubbed on brush often. Sailcloth or twill? Why? The JKU doesn't spend a lot of time on tight trails, but does go off road. Same questions.
 
The SE spends significant time on tight trails. The top gets rubbed on brush often. Sailcloth or twill? Why? The JKU doesn't spend a lot of time on tight trails, but does go off road. Same questions.
The less expensive Sailcloth is more appropriate for trail use, it's not as easily damaged as the more luxurious/expensive twill is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StG58