Thanks for weighing in guys, it is much appreciated. I have decided to go with the 1.75 lift, and stick with the 31" tire size. I am content with that since I don't plan on wheeling my Jeep. I will be placing my order within the next couple days and will post pictures when it has been installed.
You'll be happy you did. Seriously, the more lift you add, the more crap you run into, not even joking. To do a 4" lift the right way, you'll easily spend thousands.