I've been running JK wheels for a really long time. Pintlers, to be exact. I've had one issue and that was my own fault. I got in a hurry and forgot to check lug torque on the adapter. IF you're going to run JK or JL wheels, you'll need an adapter of some sort. They just don't have the offset/backspacing for a TJ. The wheels will be too far inboard.
That being said, I've been looking to get some new wheels myself. I finally found a set that meets all my conditions (17" Diameter, between 8-9" in width, 4" ± .25 backspacing, and 5 x 4.5 PCD). There are not that many out there, and almost nothing you can get new, short of some custom stuff from Method or Trail Ready. However, if you are open to used wheels, there are a few more. AEV made TJ wheels (Bridger and a Pintler, both with a 5 x 4.5 and the 4" BS). Walker Evans Beadlocks were also available in 17" with a 5 x 4.5 and 3.75-4" backspacing. That is what I found recently and decided to jump on. Everything that is "correct" for a TJ and 17" diameter is tough to get your hands on.
Going with a 16" wheel opens up quite a few more options, but it limits tire choices quite a bit.
That being said, I've been looking to get some new wheels myself. I finally found a set that meets all my conditions (17" Diameter, between 8-9" in width, 4" ± .25 backspacing, and 5 x 4.5 PCD). There are not that many out there, and almost nothing you can get new, short of some custom stuff from Method or Trail Ready. However, if you are open to used wheels, there are a few more. AEV made TJ wheels (Bridger and a Pintler, both with a 5 x 4.5 and the 4" BS). Walker Evans Beadlocks were also available in 17" with a 5 x 4.5 and 3.75-4" backspacing. That is what I found recently and decided to jump on. Everything that is "correct" for a TJ and 17" diameter is tough to get your hands on.
Going with a 16" wheel opens up quite a few more options, but it limits tire choices quite a bit.