I have the rubber plug I guess it’s the Dana 35
Check your rear axle now to determine if you have the Dana 35 which in stock form is not up to 35's, or the optional Dana 44 which is up to running that big of a tire.
Basically the perfectly oval shaped Dana 35's differential cover has a rubber plug in the lube fill hole while the stronger Dana 44 with a more angular shaped cover has a threaded bolt in its fill hole.
View attachment 186121
Look like I have the 35