@Jparish100 So I just searched my Emails. The bestop number as told to me by their service rep was 404.08P. She told me I had to call in to order the part. I ended up getting a part from ebay. That was the one I ended up shaving and putting a hole for the screw.
I ended up replacing that with the correct part from Davey's Jeep in Ohio. Sent them an email with the description of the part I wanted. They sent out the parts a couple of days later. I have used they multiple times in the past especially for OEM hard to find parts.
https://daveysjeeps.com/
Attached what they ended up sending me perfect fit.
View attachment 263156