I don't see any mid West suggestions? I like Michigan, as long as you stay out of the Detroit-metro area. You can be as remote as you want if you head north, or we have a pretty good thing going here on the SW Lakeshore if you're looking for a metro area. For instance,. My folks have about 30 acres, on a river, and they are less than 1/2 hour from downtown GR. Cost them a little over 400k... So it's a lot of money, but nothing like property value in Cali or Oregon.
Taxes aren't bad, but also not great. We have a sales tax (6%) and an income tax (4.25% flat). Property taxes vary based on where you live, but aren't horrible, I paid about 3500 a year for my modest house and City lot (which would probably sell for about 250,000 in today's market - 1850 sq ft, 3bed, 2 bath).
We're pretty conservative here too, politically. Most of Michigan is, aside from the I-94 corridor (connects Chicago with Detroit) and then the five or so counties that makes up the Detroit area. Currently governess excepted, there isn't a lot of negative politics here.
If you're a hunter gatherer type, lots of fishing and hunting opportunity here. White tail, elk (not many), bear, small game, turkey, duck, geese, etc. Coyotes are a nuscience here and the DNR had pretty much issued a shot on site order. Only need your base (small game) license for 15 bucks)
Finally... Michigan has water. Lots of water. You're never more than about a half hour from a decent lake or River for recreation. Our great lake beaches are literally some of the best in the world. Think Cancun, without the saltwater. Yes, it's than nice. This is the sleeping bear national Lakeshore
So... The negatives? Winter and the weird weather the great lakes bring (though that is largely regional). In the winter they use salt to keep the roads clear... And we all know what that does to a vehicle. Then they other thing about winter is the cloud cover. You'll have stretches of days without seeing the sun... Like 20 days in a row. It can wear on you. But we truly do have four seasons here and they are all about 3 months long.