Well crap! What seal do I want? Will the 46470 fit in there?
No. Read my posts again. The 46470 goes at the diff, but on a CAD axle, it ONLY fits at the left side. On a TJ or XJ non-CAD axle, it goes on both sides of the diff.
The CAD seal is only used if you keep a 2 piece axle. If you do not put a 2 piece YJ or XJ axle set back in, then you will not use the CAD seal, you will install the 11800 in the right side axle tube near the diff.
The long axle shaft does not have a seal surface on it at the cad end of things, so a seal installed there will just be torn up immediately.
Make your pick: pick up the 2 piece axle shafts and lock them together with a perma lock kit and install the 42500 seal
OR
keep the 1 piece TJ axle and install the 11800 seal right near the diff in the axle tube and coat it with gear oil RTV. Those are the only options.