Rough ride (I am at a loss at this point)

Try the weight suggestion above and I suspect you'll be very surprised.

Just to verify, are you suggesting I increase the sprung weight of the Jeep? If so how do I go about doing that since I have steel fenders, heavy bumpers, and a full-size spare as of now?
 
  • Face Palm
Reactions: JMT
@mrblaine could I pick your brain on what you perceive the real issue is? I know I don't even have a margin of the knowledge you have when it comes to Jeeps, and we all have to start somewhere but I am at a loss on what I'm missing, there are plenty of people with much lighter Jeeps than mine who say theirs rides like a dream? What's the difference?
 
Looking at your pics, do those skyjacker arms have just a poly bushing frame and axle side?

I’m not familiar with those arms, but if what I’m seeing is correct and there is no weird method allowing them to twist, those arms aren’t doing you any favors in the ride department.
 
I'm pretty sure it's been said that bushing material doesn't matter for ride quality but it has poly bushings
When properly installed bushing material should not have an effect on ride. The question I would have would be if those control arms/track bars etc. were tightened when the Jeep was on the ground or in the air? Clevite bushings and those poly bushings on those SJ arms could be in bind and that is never good. Easy enough to fix by loosening all the suspension bolts while the Jeep is on the ground, bouce it a few times to make sure everything is settled and then tighten everything back up. This is a really common problem when shops install suspensions while the Jeep is on a lift and they do not take the extra time to do it right.

And also welcome to 4 popper life. The suggestion that springs do not matter is not entirely accurate when you have significantly less weight over the front axle compared to the six banger which all aftermarket TJ springs cater too. Typically the problem is that you usually gain an extra inch of lift compared to a 4.0. The ride will also be a bit firmer but not should NOT be bone rattling which points me back to control arm bushings being bound up.
 
When properly installed bushing material should not have an effect on ride. The question I would have would be if those control arms/track bars etc. were tightened when the Jeep was on the ground or in the air? Clevite bushings and those poly bushings on those SJ arms could be in bind and that is never good. Easy enough to fix by loosening all the suspension bolts while the Jeep is on the ground, bouce it a few times to make sure everything is settled and then tighten everything back up. This is a really common problem when shops install suspensions while the Jeep is on a lift and they do not take the extra time to do it right.

And also welcome to 4 popper life. The suggestion that springs do not matter is not entirely accurate when you have significantly less weight over the front axle compared to the six banger which all aftermarket TJ springs cater too. Typically the problem is that you usually gain an extra inch of lift compared to a 4.0. The ride will also be a bit firmer but not should NOT be bone rattling which points me back to control arm bushings being bound up.

Thank you, I'll try that tomorrow!
 
@mrblaine could I pick your brain on what you perceive the real issue is? I know I don't even have a margin of the knowledge you have when it comes to Jeeps, and we all have to start somewhere but I am at a loss on what I'm missing, there are plenty of people with much lighter Jeeps than mine who say theirs rides like a dream? What's the difference?

If it does indeed ride very rough with the shocks pulled, you have a problem that is not spring or shock related and you need to figure out what that is. We run into the same issues when folks run too much shock on the back of an empty TJ. It is very hard to valve them soft enough to dial out the harshness. I'd pull the shocks and find a short safe place to test what is going on while you check things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blake Stamper
Okay so update, loosened to suspension and jumped on the bumper to try to get the suspension to seat before I re-torqued everything and I noticed the suspension only moved maybe 2in, I’m gonna pull shocks and see if there’s a change
 
Pulled the shocks, it was a lot less stiffer, are there any other light valves shocks I could try? I’ve used both ranches and the black maxs
 
I'm leaning towards wrong springs. If you had 5 ton springs, the axle would basically be bolted to the frame and you would have a rough ride. The springs wouldn't oscillate so your shocks wouldn't do anything. Your springs may not be 5 tons, but that doesn't mean they aren't too heavy for your jeep.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macleanflood
Hey guys, I know this is a thread that typically overpopulates the forum, I have a 99 Wrangler SE, and It's ridden like a lumber wagon since I bought it. I have been through 4 different shocks, and 2 different sets of tires, I run my tires at 24 year-round. My last pair of shocks were Rancho rs5000x, I swapped them for Skyjacker black max and I felt almost no change in how it rode. It is a base package SE it's about as light as you can get from the factory but it has a full-size spare, steel fenders, a winch, and a big front bumper, I thought for sure these shocks would help but it still doesn't ride good, axles cycle fine, I pulled my springs and cycled the suspension when I put the shocks on. They have about 6 inches of up travel front and rear, currently don't have bump stops because my local 4x4 shop didn't have any, so I'm waiting for them to come in. Does anyone have an idea of what's going on? On road, I can feel every bump on the road, and offroad on washboards it feels like Im going to bounce off the trail, I run with a bunch of guys in Tacomas and I do not want to believe that it's just a matter of IFS vs solid axle, and I really don't buy into the adage of it rides like a jeep, I just don't know what else to do other than going full blast with boarded custom-tuned shocks.

FWIW, I had this problem with my Jeep. I said “it rides like a meat wagon” on local roads. I got the rs5000x shocks and they were absolutely trash for me. I threw them in a closet and sold them later since I had painted them black and couldn’t return them (lesson learned). The ips fox shocks were valved too stiff and the adjustable rs9000x were not good but not as horrible (too bouncy on the softest settings). I was at 24 psi with 35s and plenty of up/down travel. Sway bar removed and antirock installed. RE 3.5” and Currie 4”.

I rode in Chris’s last rig that was outboarded and found my answer. I saved up and had Blaine outboard my Jeep with tuned Fox shocks and never looked back. There is no comparison. I am extremely happy.

Edit: If your rig is too stiff for you without any shocks, then my post has no value to you. My rig does not ride stiff without the shocks.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jjvw
I'm leaning towards wrong springs. If you had 5 ton springs, the axle would basically be bolted to the frame and you would have a rough ride. The springs wouldn't oscillate so your shocks wouldn't do anything. Your springs may not be 5 tons, but that doesn't mean they aren't too heavy for your jeep.

No.
 
Also I do think going through and torqing all the suspension helped, I also went through and manual cycled the shock from full extension to full compression, still not amazing by any means but it did feel better
 
Try removing the shocks again because this is interesting to me...

copy Screenshot 2023-02-24 084042.png


copy Screenshot 2023-02-24 084057.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: MikeE024
Also I do think going through and torqing all the suspension helped

Have you driven with the shocks removed since doing this?

If the ride is no longer stiff with the shocks removed, then u have made progress towards isolating the remaining problem (shocks could be too stiff after all).
 
Last edited:
Another update, toqued the rear, no change but it was worth trying anyways, I did notice something today though, I was a 4x4 event and I went on this large rock, and my tire hardly squished at all, I’m at 25 psi, for those lighter rigs out there that have ran the stt pros, did y’all notice a stiffer ride compared to like a Ko2? Anyways haven’t had time to pull front and rear shocks but thought I’d update the current progression