This thread got me curious so I checked my last fill-up numbers.
I filled up this week with about 1/4 full tank; the odometer was at something like 240+ miles, and I added 13.8 gallons.
Results = 17.4 miles per gallon. With mixed city and semi-highway driving? I'm happy with that.
(2005 Unlimited, 4.0 Inline, NSG 6-Speed Maunal, 3.73 Rear Gear, 30x9.5x15 BFG T/A KO2 Tires.)
I run ethanol-free gas too as I typically use the Jeep on a weekly, as opposed to daily, basis.