Were those Nito terragrapplers by chance? Both size tires look very goodI guess to follow up- if it were me and you plan to drive it every day, I'd do 2-2.5 inch with 265/75R16. The 285s rubbed when I was trying to pull in and out of parking spots. I spent about 2 months doing research on it (including reading a lot here!) and I decided that just because it's possible to have bigger tires it doesn't always mean it is ideal.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk