My current 02 came with a Stant locking gas cap from the previous owner, it seems to work fine so far. I had an OEM on my 05 Sport which was keyed for the ignition key. It was great. I never forgot to put the cap back on and, after the tether gave up the ghost, I never lost the cap. This worked out for about 4 or 5 years.
Until it failed.
The issue I ran into was that the lock on the cap wouldn't let go of my key. This was a weird day besides this, and I had my spare in my day pack so the solution was easy - I left my day-to-day key in the cap and drove home. You cannot imagine my relief that I had my spare, I was at a rest stop on 476 with no way to get my spare had it been at home anyway. Later I was able to get the key out with lots of patience and no tools, but it wouldn't lock into the filler, it just would spin the ratcheting part of the cap and a slight counterclockwise turn popped it out. Anyway I just went to the local Jeep dealer and bought a non-locking cap and tossed the OEM locker. It didn't throw a CEL, but I wasn't playing around with it either.
While I would love to eliminate a key from the ring, my close call keeps me from jumping on another ignition locker cap. YMMV, I am sure my story is at the far edge of extremes.
Until it failed.
The issue I ran into was that the lock on the cap wouldn't let go of my key. This was a weird day besides this, and I had my spare in my day pack so the solution was easy - I left my day-to-day key in the cap and drove home. You cannot imagine my relief that I had my spare, I was at a rest stop on 476 with no way to get my spare had it been at home anyway. Later I was able to get the key out with lots of patience and no tools, but it wouldn't lock into the filler, it just would spin the ratcheting part of the cap and a slight counterclockwise turn popped it out. Anyway I just went to the local Jeep dealer and bought a non-locking cap and tossed the OEM locker. It didn't throw a CEL, but I wasn't playing around with it either.
While I would love to eliminate a key from the ring, my close call keeps me from jumping on another ignition locker cap. YMMV, I am sure my story is at the far edge of extremes.