Thanks to everyone, I'm finally getting to the bottom of this. I'll get new spacers. So I should get 5x4.5 to 5x5 spacers that are 1.25" I believe, does that sound right?
Brand wise - from the digging I've done, spidertrax is recommended but also syngery?
[URL]https://www.spidertrax.com/Jeep-JK-Conversion-Adapters?sc=2&category=9998[/URL]
I think that is what I need. $300 for all four wheels... other brands on ebay are in the $70-$100 range for 4. I know this has probably been beaten to death is there a mid-range spacer company that builds in the usa? Synergy is another brand that pops out but I couldn't find the 5x4.5 to 5.5 at 1.25" only 1.5"
Thanks again