The harmonic balancer typically can be seen failing and the belt will wear on the outer edges more if it is-
Isolating with different size belts is a better diagnostic approach than a parts cannon.
I get the same thing on my YJ after installing a high capacity alternator and the battery is low or I have all the KC hilites on for a while. I carry a can of Belt Dressing along with a can of Wire Dry in the center console.
View attachment 542800
View attachment 542801

