@AndyG, is there a way to have false advertising show up only in a red font?
My 4yr+ soft top experience:
Almost too much heat available with top and doors on and plenty of AC even with the doors (and windows) off sometimes.
"Clean" interior when off road IF the windows and doors are closed.
Monsoon rains stay out IF the windows and doors are closed. OK Ohio doesn't get monsoons but it's never been wet from the heavy rains here.
The hard top probably is quieter than the soft top while driving but "quiet" is really a luxury car term and I bet the TJ hard top ain't that luxurious. As for security, I never keep anything that needs to be secured in my Jeep but if I had to there are at least a few options available for that.
I did think about getting a hard top when I first bought my Jeep but after the first winter those thoughts stopped. I also thought about it when branches and/or other random stuff is getting dragged over or across the soft top. Honestly, from some of the sounds I've heard I can't believe my 11 yr old Bestop doesn't have any rips or tears. I'm also pretty sure a hard top would have suffered some damage and a broken side window because it sure wouldn't have flexed like my soft top did so I don't really think about hard tops at all any more.