Although not as "stubby" as some, I like my Rock Hard 4x4 46" aka "narrow" aka "expedition width" bumper. It is available with or without a hoop and is winch ready.
https://www.rockhard4x4.com/product_p/rh-4001-c46.htm
View attachment 102888
This is the same as I have. I chose it for these features:
- No add-ons needed for my purposes. Ready to mount winch and fairlead.
- Room and holes to mount LED fog lights on outer ends.
- Tabs on the hoop to mount a small light bar.
- Seems solidly built and should serve well for recovery.
- Compatible with Currie AntiRock and ORO SwayLOC
- Simple straightforward design/appearance.
Others may provide a slightly better approach angle.