Time for a factory pitman arm.
This is my all time favorite front end correction thread.
" Figured it was time to change something....."
.....what should I do next.
This is called random parts replacement in hope of a good result. Aka, shooting in the dark.
I'm not trying to slam, but maybe a nice, gentle wedgie up over the head will help.
I see so many tjs like this....built randomly and improved just as randomly. This seldom works. Quality is never an accident.
What you need to replace are only the parts that are incorrect for the lift height, worn or damaged. And if you don't replace them with quality parts, it will either not drive better, or won't for long.
These are the basics-
Good tires. I know it's a grand or more.
Good hub/unit bearings
Correct tire pressure
Correct toe, caster and camber- proper alignment
Centered axles
Parallel axles
Solid bushings- basically all good connections , includes all control arms and the track bar (that's a control arm also)
Good Shocks
Good sway bar links help
Good ball joints
A decent stabilizer needs to be on it, but don't expect it to correct bad performance.
Learn to do a dry test, get a tape measure and let these guys help you figure out where you are on this thing, and how to get it where you want to be.
I'm not saying you have to invest $5000, but what I am saying is those are the categories. I've straightened out a bunch of them.
I fixed one Saturday that was getting squirrelly. Dry test, then 2 parts...a drag link end and a track bar. Jeep drives near new.
Stay on here. We will help you. We are the Jeep guys your mom warned you about.