Did Greg move to Indiana and become a Farmer?
Only been once but I'd go back.
It was a class A1+ charlie foxtrot. We were actually headed for "Fish Lips" next door, but they were closed. Grills was a 90 minute wait, another restaurant was closed, so we left the port area and ended up at a Red Lobster - which wasn't all that impressive although I did manage to get a pair of free earrings out of the deal.
Here's the other place I liked but it's quite a bit further from your island.
https://www.melbourneseafoodstation.com/
Here's the other place I liked but it's quite a bit further from your island.