In both cases here, if your engines are not getting up to operating temperature it is a thermostat issue, period. Specifically, the thermostat is not closing properly, or you have the wrong temp thermostat installed. The outside temp, driving at highway speeds, bad fan clutch, etc, have no impact on the minimum operating temp of the engine, which is what the thermostat establishes.
Are you familiar with the Cummins R2.8? There is a series of hoses called out to keep air out of the cooling system flow. Even though these hoses are only 3/8 inch in diameter, they are bypassing some coolant around the thermostat. In cold weather with very little engine load it is almost impossible to maintain thermostat set point on the engine. I am on thermostat #2 on my engine with only 5500 miles. The thermostat temp is 180, my engine usually will run 170 unless it is under a load and then it will exceed the thermostat temp and run around 185-190. This isn't that unusual with a diesel because when ambient air is very cold, they don't generate very much heat unless worked. I have had this same type of issue for 40 years with multiple different diesels I have owned. You wouldn't think that a stream of coolant through a 3/8 line would have much of an effect, but when temps are well below freezing it is enough to make the engine drop to 115-120 after warmed to 170 just by idling. Without the radiator blocked off, it is much worse. The hose routing specified by Cummins is pretty strange, but there must be a reason. Trapping air in the cooling system is a definate bad idea. I might try installing some restrictors in the 3/8 lines to drop the flow down to around 1/8. I know I thought about this before, but I can't remember if I did it or not. I do know that the epansion tank I used is always full and has coolant flowing through it all the time from these 3/8 lines and they bypass the thermostat.
Thanks for the explanation. Interesting setup on the R2, with which I am not familiar. I wonder if there is an issue with emissions if it can’t get up to op temp in cold weather. I have owned many diesels over the years and have never had an issue with operating temp, even in very cold weather.
I had a variable thermostat installed on mine.
Are you familiar with the Cummins R2.8? There is a series of hoses called out to keep air out of the cooling system flow. Even though these hoses are only 3/8 inch in diameter, they are bypassing some coolant around the thermostat. In cold weather with very little engine load it is almost impossible to maintain thermostat set point on the engine. I am on thermostat #2 on my engine with only 5500 miles. The thermostat temp is 180, my engine usually will run 170 unless it is under a load and then it will exceed the thermostat temp and run around 185-190. This isn't that unusual with a diesel because when ambient air is very cold, they don't generate very much heat unless worked. I have had this same type of issue for 40 years with multiple different diesels I have owned. You wouldn't think that a stream of coolant through a 3/8 line would have much of an effect, but when temps are well below freezing it is enough to make the engine drop to 115-120 after warmed to 170 just by idling. Without the radiator blocked off, it is much worse. The hose routing specified by Cummins is pretty strange, but there must be a reason. Trapping air in the cooling system is a definate bad idea. I might try installing some restrictors in the 3/8 lines to drop the flow down to around 1/8. I know I thought about this before, but I can't remember if I did it or not. I do know that the epansion tank I used is always full and has coolant flowing through it all the time from these 3/8 lines and they bypass the thermostat.
When you say very cold weather what type of temps are you talking about? I know from living in Alaska & driving truck in the western states that in very cold weather we used to run a bib on the grill to block air flow so that the engine could get up to operating temperature. But it sounds like nuffsaid might not be able to do that if he's having issues with his intercooler.
What is that? And how does it work?
when i get to the garage next time i will take a photo.
i can dial in the temp i want the thermostat to open
When you say very cold weather what type of temps are you talking about? I know from living in Alaska & driving truck in the western states that in very cold weather we used to run a bib on the grill to block air flow so that the engine could get up to operating temperature. But it sounds like nuffsaid might not be able to do that if he's having issues with his intercooler.
…
Well, not Alaska cold for sure, but New England and Colorado cold. We even get sub-zero here in Nashville occasionally. But point taken.
i didn’t drive the jeep much in the deep cold. and fairbanks is only 2 miles by six miles. no point in driving a diesel in that. it would never warm up. so i had the gas car for the winter
In Barrow it was leave it running or plugged in... Or hook up the dog team.
Good reads all around. Just got back from a glacier trip and it was roughly 10 degrees out all day.
Highway speed cruising at 70mph I maintained 180f on the Murphy gauge.
Now when I would park the jeep after wheeling and idling it would drop down to 125F.
When the motor has zero load it's just cold. Thermostat is working properly since it opens up around 183 on the freeway, zero issues.