Several of us wandered the tangled mess of trails around Central City yesterday. One of the guys had recently installed MCE flares/fenders, so I finally got a chance to study them in person.
They are everything I expected them to be. Mostly I like the flares, but there are a few aesthetic issue that stand out to me.
First, the good things.
Generally, I like the overall look. The quality of the molding and fitment is very good. The surface texture is a light orange peel and looks appropriate to the Jeep. The shape of the flare looks right, similar to Poison Spyder DeFenders, in that the lip is not thick and heavy the way most tube fenders are.
Many people, when changing to aftermarket fenders, will move the turn signals to the grill, CJ- style. I think that looks really great. This would be the perfect excuse to do that.
I've mentioned the functional benefits several times, but these seen to go unnoticed by most. MCE fenders are plastic and flexible. Most people focus on the easy understanding that you can rub the fender against a tree or rock without damage to the fender or tub. But most do not grasp that this also opens up the possibly for more suspension up travel when compared to the factory fenders.
Just like Metalcloak, MCE flares eliminate the sheet metal extending beyond the hood, allowing the tire to flex above the hood line. If your front end is bump stopped to keep the tires out of the sheet metal at full flex (as you ought to be!
), then you will be able to reduce the amount of bump stop extension to the next point of interference. With 5" of total lift, 35s and raised shock mounts, it should be possible to achieve over 6" of up travel.
Unlike Metalcloak, the wheel opening is the same. However, the Jeep I studied reportedly only rubs the bolts on the back wall of the wheel well. Short of adding bump stop, a quick fix would be to replace those bolts with a lower profile hex socket bolt. A little tire rub on a smooth surface is fine. It also looks feasible to cut the body and push the back wall of the wheel opening further back. It seems like MCE had this in mind with the way the rear of the flare was made. This would result in all the benefits of Metalcloak without the questionable video game war machine looks of MC.
There are a few aesthetic issues. The flare covers the remaining portion of the factory fender.
View attachment 46720
I feel like this is a lot of flat black space that would benefit from a body line or some other means to visually break up the space. This would be less of an issue on a black or darker color Jeep. Color matching the flares to the body would also be helpful.
The back side of the flare is only attached at the top and loosely at the bottom. The reason, as I understand it, is the allow the flare to easily detach without damaging the tub.
View attachment 46721
On the Jeep I looked at, the body was slightly rippled. I know most are. However, with the MCE not being firmly attached, the gap between the body and flare was very evident. If I end up with MCE flares, I might want to try to minimize this gap. Maybe the addition of a tab to the middle of the flare and attach it to the body with double stick tape. That is just my initial idea.
The transition from the flare to the grill isn't very clean.
View attachment 46722
At the very least, color matching the bracket to the body color would draw less attention to this area. The rest, I don't know.
The reason I have been considering MCE for so long is that I have built the suspension for maximum up travel. I do not want to lose the ability for swift comfortable travel both on and off road. The Jeep currently has 33s. If/when I move to 35s, then I will lose an inch of up if I keep the factory fenders. Traditional flat fenders don't offer any benefits to me. Metalcloak Arches/Overlines are ugly and out of the question. Poison Spyder, Nemesis, JCR, etc hi lines are the best solution for ultimate clearance. But I have so many extra things attached to the inner fenders that keeping and moving everything is a tremendous amount of work after losing that space under the hood. MCE may be the best compromise for my build.
I think that covers everything...