Thanks all for the replies — sounds like lots of opinions in both directions. Given the cost of the paint job, feels like I'm better off trying to find one in my preferred color and using that $$$ on other mods. If for some reason I can't find one I'll reconsider. Search isn't too picky I think — 03-06, <80k miles, manual, blue or black, Rubi, as close to stock as possible, obvious no rust, etc. If I spend six months or a year looking, I'll start to expand on colors (khaki is pretty nice as well but I really like the blue and black).