Like this tailgate using oem tailgate
View attachment 180066
Since I'm the guy who designed the hardtop you pictured, I can give you a couple of points to consider...
1. It is difficult to attach a factory hardtop hatch to the tailgate so that it will be securely attached and will not be prone to breaking. You can't drill mounting holes in the factory glass because it is tempered glass and will shatter when drilled, so you'd have to use adhesive to secure a mounting solution to the glass. I designed the rear door in the picture so it attaches to the tailgate with stakes, and has a strong internal shell to provide enough rigidity to provide a good seal to the hardtop. Also the glass is surrounded by the door shell so it's not prone to breakage. Here's an inside view of the rear door and how it mounts...
2. Since the factory liftgate glass is wider than the tailgate, the factory hinges will prevent a factory liftgate attached to the tailgate from swinging open. Looking at the rear of the Jeep, the right side of the liftgate glass is to the right of the tailgate hinge pin - the result of this is when the tailgate is opened, the part of the liftgate that is to the right of the hinge pin will swing inwards when the tailgate swings outward and will prevent the tailgate from opening. A solution to this problem is the TJ HD Wide-Swing Hinges from MORryde (
https://www.retrofitoffroad.com/sho...ryde-hd-tj-wrangler-tailgate-hinges-jp54-025/). I designed these hinges for MORryde, with two two goals in mine (besides being much stronger than the factory hinges)
- The hinge pin is positioned far enough to the right that a full-width rear upper door can open properly.
- By swinging wider, the hinges provide more room between the spare tire and the tail light when the tailgate is fully open, which means gear (like a Rotopax) can be mounted on the tailgate hinges without interference)
In this photo you can see the location of the hinge pins, they're to the right of the right edge of the liftgate glass:
At the same time that I did the design and mold work for the Safari Cab barn door pictured above, I did the design work for a fiberglass upper barn door for the TJ. It mounts to the tailgate the same way that the Safari Cab door does, and with the MORryde wide-swing hinges, it swings properly. I didn't make the molds for it though because I didn't think there would be enough market demand for it to make it worth the trouble.