I've been driving a TJ every single day since I bought mine brand new in 2005. It came with both hardtop and soft top. So I believe my opinion should matter on this
For the first few years, I only used the hardtop in the winter. It CAN be a pain if you don't have a hoist, and storing it is another PITA. The first time I didn't want to mess with putting the hardtop back on, I decided to just run the soft top in the winter. The
only difference I found was that it was quieter in the winter. It was still as warm with the soft top.
So I gave it a lot of thought, and sold my hardtop. I've ran a soft top ever since. To this day, I don't regret that decision. Hell I used the cash to buy an AR15!
A hardtop is a nice to have option, especially if you have the means to remove and store it.
In my honest opinion, if you own a Jeep and don’t remove the doors and top, then you’re just missing out on the point of having a Jeep. It’s freedom. It’s the experience. It’s freaking awesome.
Hell thats not an opinion, it’s a fact.