With a 2.5" lift all you want is a standard SYE, not the short or mega short options.
Those super short SYEs are good for TJs that are lifted very high.
Let's say for instance I throw on a 4" suspension lift, then do a belly-up skid that raises my transfer case about 3". That's going to put your rear driveline and pinion angle at a total of about 7" of lift, which is going to cause for a very, very steep rear pinion angle. This can cause a lot of vibrations which can sometimes be very tricky to dial out.
With that super short SYE, it lessens the steep degree of the driveshaft angle, which is going to be much better if you're dealing with vibration issues.
At 2.5" of lift though, this isn't even a concern at all. Heck, even at 4" it's nothing I would be concerned about personally.