Outdoor Auto channel did a really good breakdown on the structural difference between I think BFG TAKO3 in load range C and E. The E wasn't any stiffer, it just had a slightly different structural layup. If I remember correctly there was barely a difference in the weight. It was a really good example of old rules not applying with new tire tech.
I am with @mrblaine on quality tires generally making for a better ride and top tier tires in general having advanced massively in the last 20 years.
Hmm, interesting. I know the 15" C-rated weighs the same as the 17" D-rated but I assumed that was because there's more tire on the 15". However, looking now I see the 17-E and 17-D in the "same" size (slightly different outer diameter) are very close (the E is actually lighter!).
But okay, maybe I'm not with the times. I'm happy to be wrong on that as it means the least amount of extra money and I get to keep my moabs