It just means you were correct and I was being a dick.I needed to look up that word.... and yes....![]()
It just means you were correct and I was being a dick.I needed to look up that word.... and yes....![]()
Pedantically, yes and no. The ring and pinion are about the same strength. What isn't the same is the low pinion is being driven on the coast side of the gear tooth which is a slightly sloped tooth face when compared to the base of the ring gear. The HP is turned on the drive side which is perpendicular to the base of the ring gear.
Driving on the sloped side forces the gear teeth apart under load which then allows the pressure contact area to move out to the thinner less strong end of the tooth which can break them. The straight tooth has far less deflection and lives longer under the same loads.
I prefer a logic based "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" approach. If you build the LP 30 and find it isn't enough axle, you have some lost labor, and need a truss, stiffener, and gear set to move to the HP.Quick question that hopefully doesn't derail too much. What is your opinion on putting a lot of money into an LP30 to run 35's? How many mid arms have you done on LP30's? I have a good amount of cash sitting in my LP30 and I'm trying to decide whether to put more in or swap the axle out. Mostly looking at putting a midarm in.
I’ve had my TJ for about 2yrs now and it’s still stock. I don’t daily drive it so I put it in some pretty ugly spots as often as I can. I’ve been going back and forth with the investment into 35”s or if I could get my desired trail performance/reliability with other less $$demanding improvements. My budget is ideally 8-9k
2004 Jeep TJ Sport
4.0L Auto
Dana30front/35 rear
3.73gear
31.5”
88kmiles
So without running 5.38 gears which would require a Dana 44 I wouldn’t be running the 42rle transmission “optimally”, from what I’ve gathered most are not satisfied with 5.13 and 35”s..?
The other side of that perspective is going from a properly built rig on 33's to 35's is a body lift and the cost difference between 33's and 35's. Emphasis on properly built.I'm not discouraging 35's, just offering a different perspective.
My original post wasn’t titled info on 35”s. Idk why it changed. I was actually more interested if a properly built rig on 31.5” or 33” was as capable on a trail as just a lift and 35”s. I definitely get stuck already, most still learning which lines to take and driver error. On occasion I’ll get my frame hung up and an extra 4” would be nice. But doesn’t a 4” lift create the same difference as an extra 4” from my tire?I'm just suggesting that OP have clarity on why he is going in a particular direction with his modifications.
I wouldn't build a jeep the same way for rocky trails in the SoCal desert as I would a jeep that sees all of its offroad miles on a Florida or Texas beach or a jeep that has to break trail in deep, wet Pacific Northwest snow.
My original post wasn’t titled info on 35”s. Idk why it changed. I was actually more interested if a properly built rig on 31.5” or 33” was as capable on a trail as just a lift and 35”s. I definitely get stuck already, most still learning which lines to take and driver error. On occasion I’ll get my frame hung up and an extra 4” would be nice. But doesn’t a 4” lift create the same difference as an extra 4” from my tire?
You're honest and direct. Coming from farther north than NY, it's much appreciated and seldom seen in my current Va residence.It just means you were correct and I was being a dick.
Have I ever been any different?You're honest and direct. Coming from farther north than NY, it's much appreciated and seldom seen in my current Va residence.
I'll take a Super 35 over an 8.8 any day.
NEVER! Thank God you don't don't change in these times of whining idiots and everything being cancelled or changed because of people giving actual honest opinions.Have I ever been any different?
So true. Having had Ford trucks many years ago, I'm not a fan. Maybe I'd take a new 2021 Bronco if I win one on a game show. I'd then sell it for another TJ.I'll take a Super 35 over an 8.8 any day.
Why 35's?
Why not 33's?
Where are you going where the difference between 33's and 35's is the difference between getting where you want to go or not? Getting stuck or not? Needing a winch or not? Getting off the trail or not? Having fun or not? You get the drift.
As you can see from the growing laundry list of modifications necessary to run 35's the right way, it gets real expensive real fast.
Ask yourself if you can do what you want to do with this particular jeep on 33's. If you can, you might be able to save yourself five grand, have just as much fun, and never be in a position of being forced to cut corners to stay in budget.
I'm not discouraging 35's, just offering a different perspective.
Listen to Mrblaine. If you properly set up a build for 33s, then 35s is a BL away.I've been pondering the 33 or 35 question myself for my build, the more I've read the more I've noticed to build for 33's your within 5-6 hundred dollars of building for 35's. I might be missing something but where are you finding a 5G savings only building to 33's?