Where's
@Jerry Bransford when you need him.
He's a guy who has run both long arm and short arm lifts, so in my opinion, he's one of the few who can actually give solid, un-biased, personal opinion.
I say that because there's guys such as myself who will tell you that a short arm lift is all you need, but I'm only saying that based off advice I've taken from knowledgable folks like Jerry, Blaine and others.
Not to say a long arm lift doesn't have it's purpose. However, if you watch videos of TJs on YouTube with long arm lifts, one thing you'll notice is how often they get winded up on rocks and other obstacles.
I think that maybe the ultimate solution (at least for a lot of people) might be a mid-arm lift like the ones
@mrblaine builds. Of course everything is going to be use specific. It all depends on what you want to do with your Jeep.
DO NOT however buy into the notion that a long arm lift is better on-road. I can tell you with 110% certainty that a quality short arm lift (i.e. Currie) performs exceptionally on-road. My Currie 4" short arm lift rides like a fucking Cadillac going down the highway and over rough city roads, I kid you not.