Haha, yep... You probably should have.
Time for a new radiator, that's for sure.
Sadly I don't have time to replace the radiator myself, so, $530 later and Christian Brothers is replacing my radiator ($200 of that is for the better than AutoZone quality radiator). At least they are driving me to work!
They wanted to charge me another $500 total for changing the hoses, t-stat and gasket, flush the lines with fancy chemicals. Wayyy too much for what they would be doing!